Matt, your jumper wire is in a different location then Daryl's. Your relay is sending pwr from term 8 to 6 (top wire on right side) which should be a normally closed circuit. Daryl's is wired from 1 to 3 (top wire on left). In other words Daryl's pwr path is to the wire on term 3 and yours is the wire on 6, could be you are powering the wrong wire. It might be as simple as moving the hot leg from 8 over to term 2 and placing a jumper between 2 and 1. From what I can see the timer is powering the relay on the top, other wires going to the switches which also g to the relay on top. The powered wire on Daryl's is going to the switch not the relay from what I can tell from the pictures.