how old was it? we don't go through a ton of D white, maybe a gallon every other week but it never has a chance to turn cheesy. The only issue we have with D white is the LID, holy freakin banana balls, we can not get the D white lid to go back on for nothing. The other buckets, D base, U base, Spot black - no problem...figure that one out...
oh well there ya go.....frozen...