They want cool & different. They had seen a print I did on a Gildan vintage heather hoodie and loved the effect. I was 100% up front telling them the Independent hoodies MAY NOT produce the same effect and worst case would come out off-white on some colors.
They want the coolness, but if we could predict the future and know they'd all turn out off-white, they'd probably want a bright white. They're going to risk it with this order.
Testing isn't an option I'm offering as they're doing 4 different color hoodies and don't want to pay the cost to cover the time it would take to test. Small run on these, under 24 pieces.