Opportunity is missed by most people because it is dressed in overalls and looks like work. - Thomas Edison
I have some tricks up my sleeve for that; it's not great, but usually acceptable if that's all you have and the customer won't pay to have it recreated... post the image.steve
But at what point do we stop being copyright police?QuoteI mean, if someone sends me the NFL logo then it's hard to deny that I knew it was copyrighted... but if someone gives me this artwork how am I to know? It's not my job to research all that.Good question, How are you to know? Well, technically, yes, it is your job to know. Like a restaurant owner cooking chicken. You say it's not done and he says, "How am I to know when it's done"?The answer is, because the customer will tell you how they want it done and you continue to check it until you are comfortable and believe it to be done. Same with the copyright laws. We have the obvious, Like the NFL and Disney. ....but C'mon now, do you know how many people send me Disney stuff for a family reunion wanting em to separate something someone slapped together?but I digress. We have the obvious like the NFL and the Disney's... but we also have the obvious like this job.A, It's small in dimension. RED FLAGB, Its a pixelated jpg RED FLAG C It's 72ppi.RED FLAG D, The customers are very tight on the budget...but they have an art (image) in it's original state that would have cost $1000.00 ( at a minimum).RED FLAG I think we can all say that this customer does not own the rights or have permission and should at the least, have them confirm or deny.Quote When you send off something like this to gotprint, they don't research it. You sign a waiver saying you aren't breaking the rules and you are submitting artwork that you legally have the right to use.Ok. then. There you have it. They had you sign a waiver stating that they are not liable. You are. Do you have your sketchy customers or all customer sign off on art submissions with any kind of waiver/disclaimer? Maybe you should.The real kicker here tho is, they actually WILL still be held liable for a portion (if a judge so see's fit). It's all left up to interpenetration but just the judges, not yours or mine. Kodak has a disclaimer in your local CVS pharmacy when you get your photo's printed out. So a disclaimer must work to a degree but then again, you aren't mass producing your photo's at Kodak but for even the one off's, of photography, doesn't that say something to us if they require a disclaimer from you that says we are not steeling an image that is not ours?QuoteBeyond that what can you do?Well, I don't know. If you are operating in a mode where you take on these jobs on a regular basis, I'd say, keep back a portion of your income like we do for taxes and save for your get out of court fee's fund. Many people get away with it for years, but if someone wants to make a deal out of it, it can be done. Do what you feel you need or want to. We are our own keeper. I guess it's not the end of life as we know it when you get caught.I know plenty of shops still operating who have been caught, slapped on the hand, fined and even sued and lost but are running strong.For them, they were big enough (to be gotteen after) by someone and they were also big enough to recover from it. It was a hiccup along the way. I can say tho, when they do get caught, they change policy. Yeah sir, you betchya! It's like maybe they say, ught ooooh, I better not do that again.
I mean, if someone sends me the NFL logo then it's hard to deny that I knew it was copyrighted... but if someone gives me this artwork how am I to know? It's not my job to research all that.
When you send off something like this to gotprint, they don't research it. You sign a waiver saying you aren't breaking the rules and you are submitting artwork that you legally have the right to use.
Beyond that what can you do?
But at what point do we stop being copyright police?I mean, if someone sends me the NFL logo then it's hard to deny that I knew it was copyrighted... but if someone gives me this artwork how am I to know? It's not my job to research all that.When you send off something like this to gotprint, they don't research it. You sign a waiver saying you aren't breaking the rules and you are submitting artwork that you legally have the right to use.Beyond that what can you do?