Jason,
Don't know if you know this or not. I'm sure you tried this on whatthefont.com, but did you know when nothing is found that matches, there's a link on the bottom for "Consult the Exerts".
All you have to do is join up with a free membership and it will open up a whole lot more resources to look at your example. I joined some time back when I needed a font identified. I don't remember how long it took, but I think within a day or 2 I got an email with the font identified. Was pretty cool.
Every now and then I get a spam email from them, but not enough to be a nuisance.
Check it out.